Terminology and definitions
Gender identity/role is a relatively new term in sexology. Obviously sex and gender overlap, but the two are not synonymous. Gender encompasses sex but conceptually is more all-inclusive. That is to say, gender extends beyond genital sex to include those aspects of male and female dimorphism, behavior included, that do not pertain directly to the organs of generation and the erotic and procreative process itself. Thus, gender dimorphism applies to male/female differences in legal status, vocation, recreation, grooming, manners, and cosmetics, but it does not exclude sexual status, psychosexual status, sexuality, erotic practice, and erotic imagery.
Gender identity/role signifies the unity of gender identity and gender role. According to Money (1965), gender identity and gender role are defined as follows:
Gender identity is the sameness, unity, and persistence of one’s individuality as male, female, or ambivalent, in greater or lesser degree, especially as it is experienced in self-awareness and behavior; gender identity is the private experience of gender role, and gender role is the public expression of gender identity.
Gender role is everything that a person says and does to indicate to others or to the self the degree that one is either male or female, or ambivalent; it includes but is not restricted to sexual arousal and response; gender role is the public expression of gender identity, and gender identity is the private experience of gender role.
The differentiation and development of gender identity/role is best conceptualized as a program that involves diverse variables interacting sequentially during critical periods of prenatal and postnatal development.
X and Y chromosomes
The program of gender identity/role commences with the sex chromosomes. Nature’s plan is that the X or Y sex chromosome of the male parent, when added to the one X sex chromosome invariably supplied by the female parent, determines the genetic sex of the offspring. Should a Y chromosome be added, the chromosomal pattern is XY and, provided prenatal development goes according to plan, male differentiation occurs. Should an X chromosome be added, the chromosomal pattern is XX and, provided all goes according to plan, female differentiation occurs.
Nature’s regular plan for the X and Y chromosomes is not always the one carried out. Among human beings, the known chromosomal anomalies include the loss of either the X or Y chromosome, the addition of one or more, or the combination of more than one chromosomal pattern in the same individual. The term for this latter type of genetic anomaly is mosaicism. When mosaicism occurs, one or more supernumerary chromosomes may be present or a chromosome may be missing in some cells but not in others. An example of the latter type of mosaicism is the 45,X/46,XX pattern found in some girls with Turner’s syndrome.
Concerning chromosomal loss, it is possible for one of the X chromosomes from the XX pair or for the Y from the XY pair to be lost without lethal effect. When either occurs, the result is a phenotypic female, minus fertility, with a 45,X chromosomal pattern (Turner’s syndrome). Girls with Turner’s syndrome have gonadal streaks in the place of ovaries. Consequently, hormonal replacement is necessary for them to have a feminizing puberty. Psychosexually, they are assigned and reared as girls, and they develop a stereotypically feminine gender identity /role. By contrast, the loss of an X chromosome from the XY combination is lethal, whereas the addition of one or more X or Y chromosomes is not. Examples of two chromosomal patterns with an extra sex chromosome are 47,XXY (Kline-felter’s syndrome) and the 47,XYY. Individuals with Klinefelter’s syndrome are morphologic males who have a small penis. The testes are small and sterile. Such individuals are greatly susceptible to severe mental retardation or psy-chopathology which may be of almost any type, including the sexual psychopathology of tran-sexualism or transvestism. The occurrence of psychopathology and mental retardation is sporadic and not a consistent concomitant of the supernumerary X chromosome.
In morphologic phenotype, 47,XYY individuals are male. They are usually tall, many over six feet. Sterility is not uncommon. Money and associates (1974) compared 47,XYY individuals and 47,XXY individuals for behavioral disability, sexuality, and social interaction. Those
47,XYY individuals with behavioral disability often were found to be characterized by impulsive acting out (e.g., destruction of property) and poor long-term planning. By contrast, 47,XXY individuals often were found to be characterized by deficiency or inhibition of action (e.g., phobia). With regard to sexuality, the 47,XYY individuals showed a diversity of sexual experience, whereas the 47,XXY individuals were sexually rather inert (hyposexual). Socially, both 47,XYY individuals and 47,XXY individuals preferred being alone to being with a group.
There also exists a 47,XXX condition which occurs with a female morphology and a female gender identity/role. Fertility may or may not be diminished in this condition, and there may or may not be behavioral disability.
*1/187/5*