REVITALIZING THE LONG-TERM MARRIAGE
In the future, long-term marriages may become as obsolete as dinosaurs. No one will worry about how to preserve them, because it will be automatically assumed that you dissolve a marriage when it no longer works. Divorce is a common solution to marital woes today, of course, and many men have already gone that route once, or twice, before they reach their forties. But others are still struggling to hold together a relationship of fifteen or twenty years’ duration.
This is not an easy task, especially for a generation of men and women who were taught that you grew up, got married, and lived happily (more or less) ever after. When dissatisfactions mount, as they do almost invariably at this stage of life, there is a tendency to blame the institution of marriage itself, as if the marital relationship were something fixed and immutable.
But the fact is that marriage is a process, a fluid relationship that assumes many different forms throughout the years, a relationship that is always either growing or deteriorating. Moreover, the marital bargain that each couple makes is unique because it is based on a psychological contract incorporating their individual needs, desires, fantasies, and expectations. Frequently, however, the terms of this contract have never been openly discussed. Despite the fact that it is much more difficult to renegotiate an old marital contract than make a new one with someone else, this is the challenge facing mid-life couples who want to revitalize their relationship: To the extent that either of them has grown and changed, they will have to hammer out a new contract that accommodates these changes—a new bargain, based on old roots but purged of old rules.
Unless such an effort is made, many members of the helping professions do not hold out much hope for long-term marriages. “I’m really not convinced that our pattern of marriage is a very good one for more than twenty years,” said one marital counselor off-the-record. “Many people I see are really just dead on the vine. They live a pointless, meaningless kind of life.” Other experts claim that a muted accommodation may be the best some couples can manage. In time they settle for a static union, by detaching and disengaging from each other, because they cannot bear the conflict continually required to achieve something more creative.
When mid-life couples do decide to renew their marriage, rather than merely continue it, they generally do so only after considerable struggle and effort. Because rates of growth differ, and circumstances and interests change, two people have to face these changes and confront each other with their feelings if they are going to enliven their relationship—a painful process, indeed. Some few couples manage to do this continuously, and their partnership evolves steadily throughout the years. More often, however, resentments accumulate silently until an explosive crisis shatters the deadlock. Couples who refuse to deal with this mess either settle for a hostile truce or run to get a divorce. Others open up the hornet’s nest and work through their difficulties.
It can get very messy, but the revelation of an affair sometimes precipitates a thorough restructuring of a stagnant marriage. Consider the case of Martin V., a Detroit executive who began feeling restless and dissastisfied at thirty-eight, despite having just begun an exciting new job. Married twelve years, he and his wife, Carol, had no major problems. But he was tyrannical at home, and the tensions had built up. A taste of success made Martin feel that he deserved a more spectacular woman, a wish that led to his falling in love. Devastated when his brief affair ended, he impulsively told his wife about his romance. His confession blew open their relationship, involved months of talking, and finally resulted in their building a new way of life—together. Martin tells what happened:
I was really very immature when I married Carol, and I would yell at her a lot and try to make her into something else. She was very shy and for quite some time she just suffered quietly. I was trying to make her change, but I was also undercutting her—being critical, telling her she couldn’t do things well. Really being mean. Slowly she began to consolidate strength and get angry, and let me know she wasn’t going to take that stuff. But I hadn’t changed a great deal. So just before things blew up we weren’t arguing much and there wasn’t any open hostility, but she was sad and disappointed and confused by me. And I was impatient and uncharitable and greatly self-pitying.
I had come into the company at a much higher salary than very experienced people, and I really felt quite alone there. Sometimes panicked and scared shitless, really. So I was aggravated by the pressure, and my wife was getting more unhappy about the hours I was keeping, and things were getting tenser and tenser.
With the new work pressures I began to realize that having this suburban family life was really a terrific business handicap. And I began to think Carol wasn’t enough for me—that I needed a jazzier, more socially competent person, someone who would attract people to me and be a great hostess. I had this terrible Faustean feeling that I wanted something better, and I would trade an awful lot for it. I wanted to dress a different way, lead a different kind of life, have a different kind of wife—all that “fresh start” stuff was terribly appealing.
Then I met this woman at a party. She was a journalist—a marvelous brunette with terrific legs and a nice big chest—and she was smiling at me in the most interested way. I went right back to where I was when I was 17 years old! I really couldn’t believe anyone that nice could be interested in me!
Anyway, we talked and she was just delightful, and I asked her to dinner the next night. We went to a French restaurant, drank quite a bit and began to be very drunk and very much in love. Just tumbling into each other. Sucking each other’s fingers and exchanging wine between our lips and stroking each other—totally ignoring our meal and outraging the chef. That night she was the most beautiful woman I had ever been with!
We went back to her apartment and she said, “I’m not going to sleep with you tonight because I’m awfully tired—but we will soon.” So we kissed a lot and held each other, and then I went to my hotel room and I Stayed up all night, just thinking. I had really fallen deep! And she had even worked me into a whole marriage thing during dinner, which even at the time I knew was slightly absurd. But I kept thinking over and over, “I’m going to have to kill myself!” Not really with conviction, but the words kept springing to my lips.
I couldn’t resist calling her two days later, which was Saturday. But when I did she said she had thought about it more, and she just couldn’t risk falling in love again and losing. I went catatonic. I had to hang up after barely croaking out, “I understand”—but I was devastated. When Carol and I sat down to dinner my eyes were brimming and I just couldn’t talk. She kept asking me what was wrong, and finally I lost all control of myself and told her I was in love with another woman, but it was over. She started to shriek and got hysterical, and then we both burst into tears and I confessed the whole thing.
At first she was bitterly unhappy and kept saying it was all over for us. But we talked, we talked endlessly for two months. We’d sit up in the bedroom and talk and fall asleep, and then wake up and talk some more. We were getting it all out—all my feelings about her, and all her disappointments in me. And sometimes we had great tearful embracings and we’d make love. And sometimes I would come home at night and she would have written me beautiful long letters telling me how she felt about things. Angry letters, loving letters. There were times when I thought I had wounded her too deeply and she would never forgive me. But we went on, day by day, working it through.
There was great suffering, but we finally began to put it back together. Carol had said that if we were going to stay married she had to be part of my world—and that we would have to move into the city. That our lives had been too separate. Having a dream house and managing a demanding job—it had all soured. I loved the house but it had become a menace. So that’s what we did several months later. We moved into the city.
It has worked out beautifully. My wife isn’t isolated anymore, and she is blossoming and having a marvelous time. And now I’m with her and the kids much more and there’s more fun, more to do. Marvelous entertaining, with people pouring through our house. And Carol can dash out and join me at any old thing. These are very rudimentary things. But you alter the circumstances and you alter the essence.
We’ve had great companionship since the move, and in a funny way I feel this is sort of a second marriage. My life has changed enormously for the better—largely because of the way that whole experience was grappled with.
Though Martin’s romance may seem too brief to have threatened his marriage, the fantasy elements exerted tremendous power over him, making this affair much more significant than others he deemed “merely sexual.” His experience is by no means unique. At this stage of life, when a man is ripe for love, even a fleeting affair can stir up deep feelings.
As we have already seen, the tendency for a man to become more emotionally expressive in his forties has varying consequences. Martin’s story contains an important message for the wife who feels threatened by her husband’s mid-life changes, because it illustrates that the “other woman” is often the catalyst who releases the parts of a man’s self that had lain dormant—the tender, impulsive, caring parts. Thus despite a man’s announcing that he has simply “fallen in love” with another woman, the wife who understands that something more profound is happening will realize that her husband’s new capacity for feeling can frequently be turned back toward the marriage.
Couples who cannot cope alone with a highly charged marital crisis are turning with increasing frequency to marital counselors or psychotherapists for guidance. Such authorities generally help couples understand that an affair does not necessarily mean the end of a marriage, that they can live through it and sometimes even learn to build a better relationship than they had before.
Underlying most attempts to revitalize marriages is the notion that people grow and change, and that their relationship must too. Couples in treatment of almost any sort soon learn that they have expectations of each other that have never been discussed. They discover how to clarify, and alter, these expectations as they fashion a new foundation for the future. They also discover how to avoid rigid role-playing, express their feelings openly, and give each other more freedom to grow by becoming less dependent and possessive.
“What most people are experiencing at this stage of life is that they are not close,” says Donald Smith, the former director of New York’s American Foundation of Religion and Psychiatry, who has counseled many mid-life couples. “They are kind of bored with one another, and they just don’t feel close. It doesn’t always work, but the most effective thing we can do is help them learn to talk to one another honestly about what’s going on with them. How they are feeling about themselves, their life with one another, and their fears and anxieties. That’s the key thing.
“If they really work hard in a counseling relationship, most people learn some new things about how to communicate on a feeling level with one another. And life, therefore, gets a little bit more open and free, and a little bit more exciting— because their emotions are what’s important to them. They learn to enjoy new things, things they were unwilling to get into before. And they learn, I think, a higher level of being together.”
*63\93\2*